SC asks two hospitals to pay ₹12 lakh to father of deceased 4 yr-old rape victim
SC asks two hospitals to pay ₹12 lakh compensation for child’s death
Bharatmorningnews.com – The Supreme Court has issued a significant directive, as SC asks two hospitals to pay a combined sum of ₹12 lakh to the father of a four-year-old girl who tragically died after being denied medical treatment. This landmark order comes after the apex court found that both medical facilities in Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh, callously refused to admit the young rape victim despite her critical condition. St Joseph Hospital has been ordered to pay ₹10 lakh, while Khajan Singh Mannvi Health Care must contribute ₹2 lakh toward the compensation.
Supreme Court Bench Observations
A three-member bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V Mohana heard the case extensively. The court expressed deep concern over the callous behavior of medical professionals who allegedly turned away the dying child. When SC asks two hospitals to pay this substantial amount, it reflects the gravity of the negligence involved in this heartbreaking case.
The judicial panel carefully reviewed the findings submitted by a Special Investigation Team that was appointed by the Supreme Court to investigate the matter thoroughly. According to the detailed report, the young victim remained conscious for nearly five hours despite suffering from severe bleeding. Medical professionals at both hospitals reportedly refused to provide immediate care, ultimately resulting in her tragic demise.
Complete Timeline of the Tragedy
The incident began on March 16, when the toddler was reportedly enticed away by someone living in her neighborhood. When she failed to return home, her anxious father began searching for her and eventually discovered her unconscious and covered in blood. The heartbroken family members first approached two private hospitals, which allegedly refused to admit the child despite her critical condition.
She was subsequently transported to a government facility in Ghaziabad, where physicians unfortunately pronounced her dead. The victim’s father, who works as a daily wager to support his family, had filed a petition requesting a court-supervised investigation through either a special team or the Central Bureau of Investigation to ensure transparency.
Police Conduct Under Judicial Scrutiny
In April, the Supreme Court expressed serious concern over the Ghaziabad Police’s hesitation to register a formal complaint and initiate proper inquiries. During proceedings on April 10, the bench criticized the law enforcement agency’s “insensitive approach” toward the case, noting that delays in action may have cost the child precious time.
The court had previously served notices to the Uttar Pradesh state government, the concerned station house officer, both hospitals, and the executive magistrate. SC asks two hospitals to pay compensation not only for medical negligence but also as a deterrent against future similar incidents involving vulnerable victims.
The top court also said that it will lay broad guidelines for hospitals and the law enforcement agencies to deal with victims of grave offences. These guidelines will ensure that medical facilities and police departments work in coordination to provide timely assistance to crime victims.
Legal Implications and Future Guidelines
The bench further directed the hospitals to deposit the compensation amounts within a four-week timeframe from the order date. This directive carries significant legal weight, as failure to comply may result in additional penalties for both medical establishments.
Legal experts suggest that this case could set important precedents for medical negligence claims involving child victims. The court’s decision emphasizes the fundamental right to healthcare access, particularly for vulnerable populations who cannot advocate for themselves. Medical professionals who deny treatment to emergency cases may now face stricter scrutiny and potential disciplinary action.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which two hospitals were directed to pay compensation?
St Joseph Hospital and Khajan Singh Mannvi Health Care, both located in Ghaziabad, were ordered to pay ₹10 lakh and ₹2 lakh respectively.
What was the total compensation amount awarded?
The Supreme Court directed the hospitals to pay a combined total of ₹12 lakh to the father of the deceased four-year-old girl.
When did the incident occur?
The toddler was enticed away on March 16 and was later found unconscious and covered in blood by her father.
What are the consequences if hospitals fail to pay?
The bench has directed the hospitals to deposit the compensation within four weeks. Non-compliance may result in additional legal penalties and contempt proceedings.
Will new guidelines be issued for hospitals?
Yes, the Supreme Court has stated that it will lay broad guidelines for hospitals and law enforcement agencies to deal with victims of grave offences more effectively.